Skip to content

Mark Carney’s Plan to Check Ages of Social Media Users Risks ‘Significant Harms’ to Vulnerable Communities, Advocacy Groups Warn

The Carney government’s ‘Safe Social Media Act’ is dividing supporters as a growing number of groups say the legislation goes too far

Mark Carney’s Plan to Check Ages of Social Media Users Risks ‘Significant Harms’ to Vulnerable Communities, Advocacy Groups Warn
Photo: PMO

New legislation that could soon require every Canadian Internet user to verify their age to use many social media platforms, AI tools and other restricted websites is facing growing criticism from advocacy groups that warn the plan risks harming the very people it’s supposed to protect.

Bill C-34, the “Safe Social Media Act,” aims to regulate platforms and content in the name of protecting children. The bill proposes creating a federal regulator to oversee digital platforms and penalties for platforms that break the rules. 

But Mark Carney’s government is also controversially proposing to “ban people under the age of 16” from using social media platforms and websites, unless those platforms and websites meet undefined child-safety standards. 

We're making sure our kids are safe online.

[image or embed]

— Mark Carney (@mark-carney.bsky.social) June 11, 2026 at 3:59 PM

Bill C-34 is inspired by similar laws in Australia and Europe, although those laws haven’t gone quite as planned. Australia reports over 80% of young people are still using age-restricted platforms and France’s top court recently ruled its law banning young people from social media was unconstitutional.

While some Canadian parents may support the idea of banning their teenagers from using social media, how to even enforce such a law raises questions that might lead many to think twice.

Civil liberties and digital rights groups say in practical terms, the legislation will result in adults being forced to verify their identities (such as by uploading driver’s licences, sharing banking information or submitting to facial scans) in order to access age-restricted social media platforms and websites, something which may be unconstitutional and create barriers to accessing content that is otherwise legitimate and legal.

“Mandating that every social media user verify their age is highly invasive, while verification measures frequently create disproportionate challenges for marginalized communities,” notes the Canadian Civil Liberties Association.

“A ban will only make it more difficult for youth who inevitably bypass the measures to address the online harms they will continue to face. Those that choose to comply with the ban will be excluded from important sources of information and community.”

A number of groups that advocate for the rights of children emphasize this point. UNICEF notes “social media is not a luxury for many children, especially those who are isolated or marginalized.” The Canadian Mental Health Association, which supports Bill C-34 and has concerns about the health effects of social media on children, nonetheless agrees social media can help young people “feel connected” and “find community,” something that is of “particular relevance to young people in marginalized and rural communities.”

“Of course we’d all like young people to be in rich, fulfilling, supportive offline environments,” OpenMedia Executive Director Matt Hatfield told The Watchdog. “That’s not how life is for many young people.”

“Teens have significant and growing needs to access information privately, and parents are not always the ideal arbitrator of what a teenager needs to know. That’s particularly true, of course, for teens of marginalized sexual identities trying to figure themselves out.”

Hatfield says while OpenMedia supports regulating social media platforms, they “oppose proposals like age-verification requirements and a social media ban, with very little evidence to date of real benefit, but a great deal of evidence of risk of significant harms.”

While there is wide consensus on the need to regulate digital platforms and protect children from online harms, the Carney government’s proposed way of going about doing so is drawing criticism from groups that would otherwise be supportive of its larger aims.

Egale, which describes itself as “Canada’s leading organization for 2SLGBTQI people and issues,” has expressed concerns that Bill C-34 could “unintentionally undermine the rights, safety, or participation of communities that experience disproportionate online harms, including 2SLGBTQI communities.”

“While the Bill contains measures that could strengthen protections against online harassment and anti-2SLGBTQI hate, it also raises important concerns regarding privacy, content regulation, freedom of expression, access to community, and the experiences of 2SLGBTQI young people online,” Egale says.

They note that while the age-verification system proposed by the Carney government is “highly invasive,” these privacy concerns have even more serious implications for vulnerable communities:

“The proposed age-assurance requirements raise significant privacy concerns. Civil liberties organizations have warned that age-verification systems may require users to submit identifying information or sensitive personal data in order to access online services. For all Canadians, mandating that users verify their age can be highly invasive. 2SLGBTQI people who are not publicly out or have identification that does not affirm their identity (name, gender identity, etc.), and those in other marginalized communities that may have incomplete or insufficient information for verification, such requirements can create additional barriers to accessing information and support while also raising concerns regarding privacy and data security.”

Egale also raises concerns that Bill C-34’s “overbroad rules” on moderation could lead digital platforms to censor 2SLGBTQI voices, such as controversial topics or counter-speech: “Social media companies frequently engage in the disproportionate suppression of LGBTQ content through content removals, demonetization, and forms of shadowbanning while simultaneously failing to adequately address anti-LGBTQ hate.”

“Egale is concerned that the Bill may cause social media platforms to adopt overbroad rules targeting speech related to topics deemed controversial, including 2SLGBTQI experiences and rights, which could undermine the freedom of expression of 2SLGBTQI people and their allies in Canada.”

Federal Budget Announces Billions to Boost AI and Build Data Centres as AI Industry Faces Growing Public Backlash
Poll shows Canadians now identify AI as ‘one of the greatest threats to Canada’

The Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund, or LEAF, is an organization that “advances gender equality through law.” LEAF says that while it supports regulating platforms and harmful online content, Bill C-34’s age-verification proposal “raises serious privacy concerns.”

LEAF notes “hacking incidents targeting companies that are holding such personal information become more commonplace,” pointing to the hacking of Discord’s age-verification service in 2025 that resulted in the theft of 70,000 government-issued IDs. More recently, a breach resulted in the theft of over one million Canadian driver’s licences from an ID verification company. 

“Requiring identification to create accounts may result in barriers for women, trans, and non-binary people who are poor, precariously housed or unhoused, sex workers, migrants, and face other systemic barriers,” LEAF says.

“The focus on government-issued identification to verify someone’s age has negative implications from a substantive equality perspective for people who are precariously housed or unhoused, for trans people whose IDs may not correspond with their lived identity, and for sex workers who may want to shield their legal identity due to the criminalization of sex work.”

LEAF points out the Carney government’s legislation could disproportionately impact trans and non-binary people, in particular:

“The use of age-verification or estimation has a disproportionate impact on trans and non-binary adults who often do not have government-issued identification or banking information consistent with their gender and/or name, and who often face misgendering and exclusion by facial recognition algorithms. As a result, strict age-verification requirements may lead to trans and non-binary people being unable to access important parts of the internet.”

The organization also notes the government would be denying 2SLGBTQIA+ youth access to legitimate information and supports, particularly for those who are already experiencing social isolation:

“For many 2SLGBTQIA+ youth whose gender identity and/or sexuality are not accepted by their parents or guardians, the internet and social media remain important spaces for them to learn about and connect with members of their community, as well as express themselves. Age-verification measures may suppress legitimate expression and educational materials about one’s sexuality that could be lifesaving for some young people, especially those whose identities are not accepted by their parents, their communities, and/or their peers.”

LEAF says the Carney government’s legislation would also deny young people access to legitimate educational materials, including sexual education content:

“Imposing age-verification and age assurance can also have negative impacts on young people’s ability to access sex education online. With age-verification requirements, platforms may opt to ban content about sexuality altogether, which would impact young people’s ability to access vital information.”

The attempt to make digital platforms more child-friendly is also causing concern for other communities who believe it could be used against them instead.

The Canadian Muslim Public Affairs Council, an organization that “fights structural Islamophobia,” is concerned that the government’s approach will only lead social media companies to over-moderate their platforms, something that will result in the “disproportionate suppression of Muslim voices and perspectives in digital spaces”: 

“Online platforms are neither courts nor law enforcement agencies, yet Bill C-34 would require them to interpret highly complex legal concepts under the threat of significant financial penalties. This creates strong incentives for over-removal of content and increases the likelihood that lawful speech will be censored before any independent legal review occurs. OpenMedia expressed concern that the bill’s broad regulatory framework may incentivize platforms to over-moderate lawful content in order to avoid liability.”

OpenMedia says the “Safe Social Media Act” has the “right goal,” but the “wrong execution.” 

“We all want to make digital spaces better for young people,” Hatfield says, but he stresses “there is a huge gap between that vision and what age bans, based on existing and foreseeable age-verification methods, actually accomplish in the real world.”

“There are more nuanced, gentler approaches that can address these areas effectively without doing so much collateral damage.”

Luke LeBrun

Luke LeBrun

Luke LeBrun is the Editor of The Watchdog. His reporting focuses on Canadian politics, digital media and threats to democracy.

All articles

Help us build The Watchdog

We’re a new independent Canadian journalism publication focused on reporting about wealth, power and democracy.

Our work isn’t driven by profits or funded by dark money. We’re powered by readers like you who are helping us build and sustain a newsroom dedicated to creating high-quality, high-impact watchdog journalism.

Tags: Analysis

More in Analysis

See all

More from Luke LeBrun

See all
Subscribe section

Get The Watchdog’s Newsletter

Our free weekly newsletter brings you original investigations, analysis and explainers about wealth, power and democracy

Personal information